Global Pension Transparency Benchmark | Countries – Australia

Australia.

Australia ranked 4th globally with an average total score of 65.

The first pillar of Australia’s pension system is a means-tested, unfunded age-based pension that provides a basic benefit. The backbone of the country’s pension system is the second pillar, a mandatory defined contribution system with minimum required contributions for all workers which was introduced in 1992. Before the compulsory superannuation system was introduced, defined benefit schemes were the more popular form of occupational pension provision. The environment is competitive as individuals select the superannuation fund for their contributions. There are many superannuation providers which generally fall into two categories: not-for-profit industry funds and retail funds, which are offered to the public by financial services companies.

Overall Factor Ranking

Cost

Governance

Performance

Responsible Investment

Australia.

Cost

With an average cost factor score of 67, Australia’s superannuation funds ranked 3rd globally. Individual scores ranged from 58 to 84. Four of the funds offer DC options in a competitive environment, so the questions relating to completeness of external management and transaction costs were all from the perspective of product disclosure statements to members. Some of the Australian funds did a very good job of including all transaction costs (including implicit ones like market impact, buy and sell spreads, etc.) and quantifying and disclosing this to members. Commendable and not typical relative to funds globally.

Governance

The Australian funds did very well on this factor with an average score of 72, second behind Canada. The range of scores was quite narrow: from a low of 65 to a high of 80. Funds scored well in all areas except organisational strategy, which was a surprise since all super funds are fully integrated investment management and member service organisations. Members would benefit from a clearer picture of where their super fund is heading. Where the Australian funds did particularly well was in disclosures on compensation, human resources and organisation, receiving the top grade in this area. Compensation disclosures for both the board and management were especially impressive – all funds received top marks.

Performance

The Australian funds scored well in performance with an average country score of 76 and a global ranking of 4th on the factor. Scores were quite consistent across funds, ranging in a narrow band from 66 to 86. Scores on most performance components were around the top-quartile mark with two outliers. Benchmark disclosures were relatively weak at the asset class level. In contrast, the Australians had the highest average score on disclosures for member service levels. It seems the competitive environment and freedom that individuals enjoy to switch funds drives more emphasis on member service.

Responsible Investing

The Australian funds had an average country score of 46 on RI and ranked 8th globally. Individual fund scores ranged widely from a low of 8 to a high of 70. Areas of relative strength were: active ownership policies, ranked 4th with an average score of 72, and exclusion policies and practices ranked 4th with an average score of 70. Disclosures in other areas were generally mid-range relative to other countries.

Examples

AustralianSuper

AustralianSuper shows a clear and concise breakdown of total and transaction fees for their different fund options on their website.

Source: AustralianSuper website

First State Super

First State Super has a very good breakdown of the estimated investment fees annually by investment option. This annual report was produced in 2019 prior to the merger and name change to AwareSuper.

Source: First State Super Annual Report 2019 (page 16)

Overall Results
Australia.

View all rankings

	Min	Avg	Max	Rank	Min BR	Avg BR	Max BR	Rank BR	Min CA	Avg CA	Max CA	Rank CA	Min CH	Avg CH	Max CH	Rank CH	Min DE	Avg DE	Max DE	Rank DE	Min FI	Avg FI	Max FI	Rank FI	Min JA	Avg JA	Max JA	Rank JA	Min ME	Avg ME	Max ME	Rank ME	Min NE	Avg NE	Max NE	Rank NE	Min NO	Avg NO	Max NO	Rank NO	Min SA	Avg SA	Max SA	Rank SA	Min SW	Avg SW	Max SW	Rank SW	Min SZ	Avg SZ	Max SZ	Rank SZ	Min UK	Avg UK	Max UK	Rank UK	Min US	Avg US	Max US	Rank US
Performance	66	76	86	4	35%	51%	67%	15	75%	84%	90%	2	52	59	70	13	51%	61%	70%	12	64%	69%	77%	7	47%	69%	86%	8	50%	55%	67%	14	62%	69%	74%	6	46%	67%	93%	9	56%	66%	80%	11	73%	77%	82%	3	56%	70%	84%	5	61%	66%	76%	10	79%	87%	94%	1
Governance	65	72	80	2	40%	43%	45%	12	72%	86%	97%	1	38	51	63	9	47%	63%	91%	4	38%	57%	71%	7	18%	28%	41%	14	0%	17%	42%	15	43%	56%	69%	8	22%	48%	64%	10	43%	60%	77%	6	64%	70%	78%	3	26%	42%	78%	13	48%	63%	86%	5	31%	47%	59%	11
Cost	58	67	84	3	38%	57%	70%	6	59%	69%	83%	2	25	39	51	12	41%	51%	59%	8	18%	28%	31%	14	30%	38%	46%	13	19%	23%	26%	15	71%	83%	88%	1	18%	42%	64%	10	34%	46%	63%	9	43%	57%	70%	5	40%	65%	82%	4	42%	56%	71%	7	24%	41%	59%	11
Responsible Investing	8	46	70	8	8%	19%	27%	13	47%	58%	66%	4	2	6	11	14	46%	61%	74%	3	13%	58%	81%	5	0%	20%	40%	12	0%	2%	5%	15	58%	71%	79%	2	6%	47%	79%	6	8%	40%	57%	9	66%	73%	88%	1	18%	29%	49%	11	24%	47%	63%	7	5%	35%	64%	10
Total	50	65	79	4	34%	43%	52%	12	69%	74%	82%	1	30	38	42	14	55%	59%	68%	5	33%	53%	63%	7	24%	39%	48%	13	18%	25%	33%	15	59%	70%	78%	2	34%	51%	73%	11	44%	53%	63%	8	65%	69%	74%	3	43%	52%	71%	10	50%	58%	65%	6	38%	52%	67%	9

Australia.

Australia ranked 4th globally with an average total score of 65.

Overall Factor Ranking

Cost

Governance

Performance

Responsible Investment

Australia.

Cost

Governance

Performance

Responsible Investing

Examples

AustralianSuper

First State Super

Overall Results
Australia.

Funds Analysed

AustralianSuper

Aware Super

Future Fund

QSuper

UniSuper

Australia.

Australia ranked 4th globally with an average total score of 65.

Overall Factor Ranking

Cost

Governance

Performance

Responsible Investment

Australia.

Cost

Governance

Performance

Responsible Investing

Examples

AustralianSuper

First State Super

Overall Results Australia.

Funds Analysed

AustralianSuper

Aware Super

Future Fund

QSuper

UniSuper

Overall Results
Australia.