Countries 2024
Promoting transparency for better pension outcomes
Select country to see results
- Australia
- Brazil
- Canada
- Chile
- Denmark
- Finland
- Japan
- Mexico
- Netherlands
- Norway
- South Africa
- Sweden
- Switzerland
- United Kingdom
- United States
Australia.
Australia ranked 2nd with an overall average total score of 82.
The first pillar of Australia’s pension system is a means-tested, unfunded age-based pension that provides a basic benefit. The backbone of the country’s pension system is the second pillar, a mandatory defined contribution system with minimum required contributions for all workers which was introduced in 1992. Before the compulsory superannuation system was introduced, defined benefit schemes were the more popular form of occupational pension provision.
The environment is competitive, individuals are permitted to select the ‘superannuation fund’ of their choice for their contributions. There are many superannuation providers, or supers, which can generally be categorised as either being 1) not-for-profit industry funds or 2) retail funds which are offered to the public by financial services companies. Most of the largest funds are in the not-for-profit industry sector.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Australia.
Funds Analysed
Australian Retirement Trust
Australian Retirement Trust is the superannuation fund formed through the merger of Sunsuper and QSuper. It is one of Australia’s largest super funds and proud to take care of over A$240 billion in retirement savings for 2.2 million members. As a fund that works for members, not shareholders, it is committed to working in members’ best interests, and is committed to returning profits to them as lower fees and better services.
AustralianSuper
AustralianSuper is the largest Australian superannuation and pension fund, with approximately one in every 10 Australian workers as members. It is a not-for-profit industry superannuation fund.
Aware Super
Aware Super is a not-for-profit industry fund with a new name but a history going back to 1992. It is Australia’s third largest largest fund, with $150 billion under management following the merger between First State Super, VicSuper and WA Super.
Future Fund
Future Fund is Australia’s sovereign wealth fund, responsible for investing for the benefit of future generations of Australians. Future Fund was established in 2006 to strengthen the Commonwealth’s long-term financial position and manages six public asset funds.
UniSuper
UniSuper is a not-for-profit superannuation fund with origins as a provider of superannuation for employees of Australia’s higher education and research sector.
Brazil.
Brazil ranked 12th globally with an average total score of 50.
In Brazil, the first pillar consists of two schemes. The General Regime of Social Security (RGPS) is a mandatory scheme covering the private-sector workforce. The Regime of Social Security for Public Servants (RPPS) includes multiple pension schemes covering public sector employees. In general, these pension plans are financed on a pay-as-you-go basis with the employee paying a percentage of their salary.
The first pillar is complemented by a voluntary, private savings scheme called the Complementary Pension Regime (RPC). Employer sponsored pensions have a long history in Brazil and the country has the oldest system in Latin America. Two pension vehicles exist that can be used to finance private pension benefits. Closed private pension entities are non-profit organisations that can be established on a single-employer or multi-employer basis and by labor unions. Authorised financial institutions also provide pensions through open private pension entities. The closed approach is typically chosen by large employers whereas the open approach is mostly chosen by small and medium-sized employers and offered to their employees. Closed funds, sponsored mainly by large private companies, traditionally provided defined benefit pensions. Like many other countries, Some of these DB plans are now closed and DC plans are on the rise.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Brazil.
Funds Analysed
Funcef
Funcef is the third largest pension fund in the country, with more than R$70 billion in assets and 135,000 participants. Its members are employees of CAIXA, a Brazilian bank that is the largest 100% government-owned financial institution in Latin America.
Itau Unibanco
Itau Unibanco provides a number of pension schemes for its employees and for subsidiary companies. Itau Unibanco is the largest private sector bank in Brazil and the largest in Latin America. It has operations in eight countries in the Americas as well as eight other countries.
Petros
Petros is a pension entity created by Petrobas, the national oil company. It has legacy DB plans for Petrobas and subsidiary companies, newer DC plans for them, and it now offers pension plan services for other employers and organisations in Brazil.
Previ
Previ has a long history, dating back to 1904. It is now among the largest pension funds in Latin America. Previ is the pension fund for employees of Banco do Brasil, and its own employees. There are two main plans: a DB scheme that has been closed to new entrants for some time, and a newer, open DC plan – Previ Futuro.
Vivest
Vivest was known as Funcesp until recently and it started as a provider of pension and health benefit programs for CESP, a large electricity generation company in the State of São Paulo. Today, Vivest is the largest private pension fund in Brazil.
Canada.
Canada ranked 1st globally with an average total score of 91.
Canada’s pension system is characterized by a mixture of public and private pension schemes. Approximately half of all Canadians rely on the public pension system which consists of two tiers: 1. Old age security – set amounts paid to all Canadians of retirement age, based solely on residency 2. Canada Pension Plan (CPP) – a mandatory earnings related pension covering all workers. The third tier of Canada’s pension system is made up of voluntary pension savings. Defined benefit plans remain the most common type of scheme in Canada, particularly for public sector employees. Like many other countries, defined contribution plans are now the plan of choice for private sector employers. We reviewed the public disclosures of the CPP and four organisations that manage mainly DB plan assets for provincial public sector employers.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Canada.
Funds Analysed
British Columbia Investment Management Corporation (BCI)
BCI manages the assets of public sector pension plans as well as insurance and benefit funds for the province of British Columbia.
Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec (CDPQ)
CDPQ invests funds for several public and parapublic pension plans and insurance programs in the province of Quebec.
CPP Investments (CPPIB)
CPPIB manages the assets of the Canada Pension Plan, the national pension scheme for Canadian workers.
Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan (OTPP)
OTPP is responsible for managing plan assets and administering defined-benefit pensions for school teachers in the province of Ontario.
Public Sector Pension Investment Board (PSP)
PSP invests funds for the pension plans of the Public Service, the Canadian Armed Forces, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police and the Reserve Force.
Chile.
Chile ranked 14th globally with an average total score of 47.
In 1981, Chile introduced a mandatory defined contribution pension system. Employees are required to contribute 10 per cent of their salary and choose a private Pension Fund Administrator (AFP). AFPs are chartered as pension providers by the Chilean government and compete for individual accounts. This pension system has become known as the ‘Chilean Model’ and versions of it have been implemented in other Latin American countries. The public disclosures of the largest Chilean private sector Pension Fund Administrators (AFPs) were reviewed.
AFP investment programs are dictated by regulation. AFPs are allowed to offer up to five investment funds, called Funds A to E, which have different proportions of their portfolios invested in equities. All AFPs must offer funds B to E, while fund A, the highest equity/highest risk fund is optional. All funds operate within regulated investment limits that cover investments in various asset classes and investment vehicles. AFPs must meet a minimum level of return for each fund that is tied to the average return for all funds of that type. There is a guarantee obligation that requires AFPs to top-up their underperforming funds. Not surprisingly, most AFPs invest in a similar way to ensure they are not required to inject capital into their funds.
AFPs set the administration fees they charge members, but the fee must be the same percentage of salary for all their members. These fees are known as commission and are applied to contributions into the funds. Commissions are intended to cover all AFP costs and generate a profit margin.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Chile.
Funds Analysed
Capital
Capital is an AFP that is part of Grupo SURA, a Colombian company that offers pension fund management and other financial services in Chile and several other Latin American countries.
Cuprum
Cuprum is an AFP with more than 35 years of history in the Chilean pension system and its inception is tied to the copper mining sector. Cuprum is now part of the Principal Financial Group, a large global financial services company headquartered in the United States.
Habitat
Habitat is the second largest Chilean AFP by assets under management. It also owns pension fund management companies in Peru and Colombia. In 2016, Prudential Financial, a large US global financial services company purchased an interest in Habitat.
Modelo
Modelo is a relatively new domestically owned AFP. It commenced operations in 2010 and has grown quickly.
Provida
Provida was founded in 1981 and is the largest Chilean AFP by assets under management. Provida is now part of MetLife, a large US global financial services company.
Denmark.
Denmark ranked 5th globally with an average total score of 70.
The public disclosures of the largest Danish pension providers were reviewed. The country’s primary public pension system consists of a basic pension and a pension supplement paid to the most financially disadvantaged. This primary pension is supplemented by ATP Lifelong Pension, to which most people contribute. Certain employees also participate in mandatory occupational pension schemes determined by collective bargaining. In combination, these programs cover about 90 per cent of the employed workforce.
Almost all plans in Denmark are of the defined contribution type, in part driven by the prevalence of industry-wide collective labour market agreements. The collective bargaining agreements often mandate both employee and employer participation in supplementary schemes, so while technically voluntary, participation is effectively compulsory. The occupational pension pillar is chiefly funded by employees paying into these schemes. The occupational schemes themselves are offered by a variety of providers who compete for the same customers.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Denmark.
Funds Analysed
ATP Group
ATP Group is Denmark’s largest pension and processing company with 5.2 million members and pension assets exceeding DKK900 billion. It provides lifelong pensions to Danish citizens.
Industriens
Industriens manages a compulsory labour market pension scheme with approximately 400,000 members from approximately 8,000 companies. It is a defined contribution scheme with assets of approximately DKK200 billion. Profits are returned to the members.
Pension Danmark
Pension Danmark is a member-owned labor market pension fund with DKK260 billion under management. It serves approximately 750,000 members from 23,400 companies.
PFA Pension
PFA Pension is Denmark’s largest commercial pension, insurance, and healthcare products company. It manages pension assets of more than DKK680 billion for more than 1.3 million members.
Sampension
Sampension is a customer-owned pension company with assets of close to DKK300 billion and around 300,000 customers. It manages industry-wide pension schemes for white collar employees in Danish municipalities and central government.
Finland.
Finland ranked 8th globally with an average total score of 64.
The base of Finland’s pension system consists of a flat rate government pension called the national pension which provides up to 20 per cent of the average wage. Supplementing the national pension are mandatory earnings-related plans provided by employers through several pension insurance companies. The mandatory earnings related plans are funded by contributions from both employees and employers. Voluntary pension plans are not common and are generally only put in place for executives.
One of the funds reviewed is the fund that manages the assets backing the national pension (VER). The other four organisations are pension insurance organisations which manage assets and administer benefits backing the mandatory earnings-related plans.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Finland.
Funds Analysed
Elo
Elo is a large pension insurance company which provides services to both employers and individuals.
Ilmarinen
Ilmarinen is a mutual pension insurance company owned by its members and offers pension services to both employers and the self-employed.
Keva
Keva is Finland’s largest pension provider and administers the pensions of Local Government, State, Evangelical Lutheran Church and Keva employees.
Varma
Varma is a mutual pension insurance company owned by its members and offers pension services to both employers and the self-employed.
VER
VER is the state pension fund of Finland and manages the assets backing the base government pension.
Japan.
Japan ranked 13th globally with an average total score of 48.
The public disclosures of the five largest pension fund organisations in Japan were reviewed. The Japanese organisations include the fund backing the social security system, three organisations that manage funds for public sector workers and one fund that manages pension assets for private sector workers.
Japan’s pension system backbone is the national social security system – National Pension Service. Workplace pensions that supplement the National Pension Service are common for both private and public sector workers and have traditionally been defined benefit in nature. Earlier in this century, defined contribution style arrangements were introduced and those who do not a have a workplace pension may set up an individual defined contribution account with the Pension Fund Association.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Japan.
Funds Analysed
Government Pension Investment Fund (GPIF)
GPIF is the largest pension fund in the world and manages assets for Japan’s National Pension Service, the government social security system.
Federation of National Public Service Personnel Mutual Aid Associations (KKR)
KKR manages pension funds for national public service personnel as well as offering pension and other medical and welfare services.
National Federation of Mutual Aid (Shichousonren)
National Federation of Mutual Aid (Shichousonren) manages pension assets for the Mutual Aid Associations for Personnel of Designated Cities, 47 Mutual Aid Associations for Municipal Personnel, and three Mutual Aid Associations for Personnel of Cities.
Pension Fund Association
Pension Fund Association manages assets and administers benefits for corporate pension plans and workers who have left plans, allowing them to aggregate pensions from different employers. The Pension Fund Association also allows private sector employees who do not have a company pension to set up individual defined contribution accounts.
Pension Fund Association for Local Government Officials (Chikyoren)
Chikyoren manages pension assets for the Local Public Service Personnel Mutual Aid Association.
Mexico.
Mexico ranked 15th globally with an average total score of 35.
The public disclosures of the five largest private pension fund managers, known as Afores, were reviewed. Mexico reformed its pension system in 1997 and instituted a fully funded, private and mandatory defined contribution system. The reform was modeled after the pension reforms in Chile in the early 1980s. Afores are responsible for managing individual accounts and investing contributions. They are chartered by the Mexican government and compete for individual accounts.
Afore investment programs are dictated by regulation. As of 2019, the Afores must offer 10 ‘Siefore’ generational funds. The Siefores are structured like target date funds: the contributions of each member are assigned to the Siefore associated with their date of birth and remain there throughout their working life. Regulations stipulate investment limits that cover investments in various asset classes and investment vehicles. Contributions are currently set at 6.5 percent of wages.
Afores set the administration fees they charge members, but the fee must be the same percentage of salary for all their members. These fees are known as commission and they are applied to contributions into the funds. Commissions are intended to cover all Afore costs and generate a profit margin.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Mexico.
Funds Analysed
Banorte
Banorte is the largest Mexican Afore by assets under management. It is domestically owned and is part of Grupo Financiero Banorte, a large Mexican banking and financial services company.
Citibanamex
Citibanamex is the second largest Mexican Afore by assets under management and it is part of the Banamex Financial Group, a large Mexican financial services company, which is a Citigroup subsidiary. Citigroup is a large American multinational investment bank and financial services company.
Principal Afore
Principal Afore is part of the Principal Financial Group, a large global financial services company headquartered in the United States.
Profuturo
Profuturo is the fourth largest Mexican Afore by assets under management. It is part of Grupo Bal, a large Mexican conglomerate that participates in financial services and several other industry sectors.
Sura
Sura is the fourth largest Mexican Afore by assets under management. It is part of Grupo SURA, a Colombian company that offers pension fund management and other financial services in Mexico and several other Latin American countries.
The Netherlands.
The Netherlands ranked 3rd globally with an average total score of 81.
The five Dutch funds reviewed were a homogenous group representing various occupational defined benefit pension funds. All are organised as a non-profit with a board representing employees, employers and trade unions where applicable. All outsource asset management and benefit administration services to third party providers (eg APG and PGGM). Historically, the funds and administration service providers were typically one entity but were separated in the early 2000s. This separation gave the pension funds autonomy and the ability to go elsewhere for services.
The Dutch pension system is considered one of the best in the world. Two regulators, the Dutch Central Bank (DNB) and the Dutch Authority for the Financial Markets (AFM) oversee the system. On top of this, there is a very active association, Pensionefederatie, an association of 198 pension funds that promotes the interests of members of pension funds. The annual reports reviewed all followed the disclosure practices recommended by this association.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
The Netherlands.
Funds Analysed
Stichting Pensioenfonds ABP
Stichting Pensioenfonds ABP (“National Civil Pension Fund”), frequently referred to as ABP, is the pension fund for government and education employees. It is the largest pension fund in the Netherlands, with assets of €465 billion, and among the five largest in the world. It serves about three million members. ABP’s benefit administration and asset management operations are outsourced to APG.
Pensioenfonds Zorg en Welzijn (PFZW)
PFZW is the pension fund for the healthcare and welfare sector. It is the second largest pension fund in the Netherlands with AUM of €266 billion and over two million members. PFZW’s benefit administration and asset management operations are outsourced to PGGM.
Pensioenfonds Metaal & Techniek (PMT)
PMT is the pension fund for the metal and technical sectors. PMT is the country’s third largest pension fund covering 34,300 employers and 1.4 million plan participants. Benefit administration and asset management operations are outsourced to MN.
Stichting Bedrijfstakpensioenfonds voor de Bouwnijverheid (BOUW )
BOUW is the pension fund for the building and construction industry. BOUW serves as the collective pension fund the 780,000 plan participants of 13,100 companies. BOUW’s benefit administration and asset management operations are outsourced to APG and Bouwinvest.
Pensioenfonds Metalektro (PME)
PME is the pension fund for the metal and technology industry, covering a range of industries including , shipping, automotive, and semiconductor manufacturers. In total, more than 1,390 employers and 626,000 participants are covered by PME. Benefit administration and asset management operations are outsourced to MN.
Norway.
Norway ranked 7th globally with an average total score of 66.
The Norwegian pension system consists of a public pension system, a mandatory occupational system plus personal pension saving provisions. The state pension scheme provides a flat rate basic pension plus an earnings-related supplement that covers all employed and self-employed persons. Occupational pension schemes can be funded through an insurance contract or a pension fund. Historically defined benefit schemes were the dominant form of occupational schemes but new defined contribution schemes are becoming increasingly popular. About 75 percent of private pensions in the Norwegian pension system are funded via insurance contracts. The reviews consisted of two funds supporting the public pension system, two funds managing assets for public employees and the largest corporate pension fund in Norway.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Norway.
Funds Analysed
Equinor Pension Fund
Equinor Pension Fund is a pension fund covering employees of Equinor, the largest energy company in Norway that also has operations in 30 countries. Equinor was known as Statoil until 2018.
Government Pension Fund Global
Government Pension Fund Global: This global investment fund derives its financial backing from the oil industry and is managed by Norges Bank Investment Management (NBIM), part of the Norwegian Central Bank on the behalf of the Ministry of Finance. It is the largest pension fund in Europe.
Government Pension Fund Domestic
Government Pension Fund Domestic: This fund was established by the National Insurance Act in 1967 under the name National Insurance Scheme Fund. It is managed by Folketrygdfondet and can only invest domestically.
KLP
KLP is a mutual insurance company, established in 1949, responsible for the management of municipal and county pensions and insurance issues.
Oslo Pension Fund (OPF)
Oslo Pension Fund (OPF) provides pension and insurance management services for employees of the City of Oslo and several other public organisations under its jurisdiction.
South Africa.
South Africa ranked 10th globally with an average total score of 55.
The South African pension system consists of a means-tested, non-contributory government social security system supplemented by voluntary occupational retirement schemes.
The five South African funds that were reviewed are not a homogenous group. They included two defined benefit plans: GEPF, one of the world’s largest funds and the national electricity utility, Eskom. The other funds are ‘umbrella’ funds, defined contribution providers that compete for employer and individual members. Umbrella funds offer business owners and their employees the opportunity to join a larger established retirement fund while retaining some flexibility in plan design and features.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
South Africa.
Funds Analysed
Eskom Pension and Provident Fund (EPPF)
EPPF provides investment management and benefit administration services for the defined benefit plan for employees of Eskom, South Africa’s public electrical utility company.
Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF)
GEPF is a defined benefit fund that manages pensions and related benefits on behalf of government employees in South Africa. GEPF is by far the largest pension fund in South Africa and one of the largest in the world.
Old Mutual SuperFund
Old Mutual SuperFund is South Africa’s first ‘umbrella’ fund, introduced by Old Mutual in 1992. Old Mutual is a large diversified financial services company that operates in 14 African countries.
Sanlam Umbrella Fund
Sanlam Umbrella Fund is a defined contribution fund offered by Sanlam, part of the Sanlam Group, a large, diversified financial services company with operations in 44 emerging and developed market countries.
Sentinel Retirement Fund
Sentinel Retirement Fund was founded in 1946 and originally served the mining industry. It converted to an umbrella pension fund that is now open to all industries and employers in South Africa. Sentinel has a mutual, not-for-profit business model.
Sweden.
Sweden ranked 4th globally with an average total score of 77.
Sweden’s pension system consists of an earnings based “income pension” funded on a pay-as-you-go basis by employee and employer contributions of 16 per cent of earnings. An additional 2.5 per cent of earnings is paid into a funded government sponsored defined contribution “premium pension”. Reserves backing the income pension are divided evenly between four state run buffer funds, AP1, AP2, AP3, and AP4. In addition, employees covered under a collective agreement (most Swedish employees) also receive a separate occupational pension. There are four different pension collective agreements: SAF-LO, for privately employed white collar workers; ITP, for privately employed blue collar workers; KAP-KL/AKAP-KL, for employees within local government; and PA 16, for Swedish civil servants.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Sweden.
Switzerland.
Switzerland ranked 11th globally with an average total score of 54.
The Swiss pension system is founded on three pillars. The first is a state-run pension scheme for seniors, orphans, and surviving spouses. The second pillar consists of pension funds run by investment foundations, which are tied to employers. The third pillar is composed of voluntary private investments. The plans that were a part of this review primarily fall under the second pillar.
The review included three public institutions, including the fund responsible for investing assets backing social security and two of the largest private pension funds. The public institutions managed assets primarily for public workers or pensioners tied to the Confederation, specific cantons, or communes within Switzerland.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
Switzerland.
Funds Analysed
BVK
BVK is the pension fund for employees of various entities of the canton of Zurich. BVK covers more than 124,000 members 450 affiliated employers and has pension assets of 35 billion Swiss francs.
Compenswiss
Compenswiss is an independent public institution that manages and administers the Swiss Federal social security funds.
Migros
Migros is Switzerland’s largest retail company, supermarket chain, and employer. It manages the pensions of over 80,000 members, representing assets of almost 26 billion Swiss francs.
PUBLICA
PUBLICA is an independent pension institution that is comprised of 13 open and seven closed pension plans, managed on behalf of public entities in the Swiss Confederation. PUBLICA covers more than 100,000 members and has total assets of 41 billion Swiss francs.
SBB
SBB is Switzerland’s national railway company. The pension fund manages the assets of 55,000 members, representing total holdings of almost 19 billion Swiss francs.
United Kingdom.
The United Kingdom ranked 9th globally with an average total score of 61.
The UK has a very mature pension industry underpinned by a national pension scheme which is paid from National Insurance Contributions – a payroll tax. This national pension scheme is supplemented by both occupational and individual pensions. Defined benefit schemes were once popular among private sector employers, but virtually all have closed and many are now frozen. A robust insurance market has developed offering employers many options for reducing or eliminating their legacy defined benefit liabilities. Defined contribution plans are now the norm for private sector workers while most public sector workers still accrue defined benefits.
Pensions for the public sector are mostly provided through a series of nationwide occupation-based pension schemes. These schemes are unfunded. As a result four of the five funds reviewed were private sector pension schemes. The other organisation is the government fund set up to protect private sector defined benefit members in the event of insolvency.
More recently, the UK has required all private sector employees to be enrolled into defined contribution style arrangements. Employees may opt-out of these arrangements. There are several providers of define contribution style arrangements including a public competitor designed to be a low-cost and efficient fund manager, called the National Employment Savings Trust (or “NEST”). It is anticipated that in future years, some of these providers were grow such that they supersede some of the corporate funds in our review.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
United Kingdom.
Funds Analysed
BT Pension Scheme
BT Pension Scheme is the UK’s largest corporate defined benefit pension scheme with assets of about £40 billion ($60 billion). The scheme closed to new members in 2001 but remains responsible for securing the long-term financial wellbeing of approximately 320,000 current and future pensioners.
Lloyds Bank Pension Scheme
Lloyds Bank Pension Scheme No. 1 is a pension scheme for employees of Lloyds banking group which has both a closed defined benefit provision and defined contribution provision.
NatWest Group Pension Fund
NatWest Group Pension Fund (formerly the Royal Bank of Scotland Group Pension Fund) is the defined benefit pension fund for employees of NatWest Group.
Pension Protection Fund
Pension Protection Fund is a statutory fund which holds assets to be used to protect members of defined benefit plans if their pension fund becomes insolvent.
Universities Superannuation Scheme
Universities Superannuation Scheme is the largest private sector pension fund in the UK and is the principal pension scheme for universities and higher education institutions in the UK.
United States.
The United States ranked 6th globally with an average total score of 69.
The public disclosures of the five largest pension fund organisations were reviewed. All organisations reviewed manage funds backing the pension entitlements of public sector workers. The United States has a large, mature and fragmented pension market. Many states as well as some counties and municipalities have one or more plans for their public sector employees. Private sector pensions are provided by employers or employer/employee associations. On a federal level, social security provides retirement and other benefits, paid by a combination of payroll taxes and a reserve fund.
Historically, defined benefit plans were the predominant type of retirement plan for both public and private sector workers. Since the turn of the century there has been a concerted move away from defined benefit structures to cash balance and pure defined contribution structures among private sector employers. Pension arrangements for public sector employees are still commonly defined benefit plans, although the last 10 years has seen hybrid defined benefit/defined contribution designs become more common.
Pension arrangements in the United States are highly regulated. Private sector arrangements are governed by ERISA whereas public sector pensions follow regulations determined by the respective state legislative bodies. In addition to these regulations, pension plans must also abide by tax regulations. In fact, it is sections of the US tax code that give rise to the names of many defined contribution arrangements in the US such as 401(k), 403(b), and 457 plans.
Overall Factor Ranking
Cost
Governance
Performance
Responsible Investment
Overall Results
United States.
Funds Analysed
CalPERS
CalSTRS
New York City Bureau of Asset Management
New York State Common Retirement Fund
Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board
Insights
Norway SWF tops list of most transparent funds globally
Government Pension Fund Global, Norway’s giant sovereign wealth fund, has topped the list of the...
Canada, The Netherlands lead the way on pension transparency
Canada is a standout in the transparency of pension fund reporting, topping the list of countries...
GPTB 2023: The funds that excelled
The highest scoring funds overall in the 2023 Global Pension Transparency Benchmark were also...
Transparency improvements but more work needed on cost disclosure
Funds around the world improved their scores on responsible investment disclosure by more than on any of the three other factors assessed in the...
Funds need to evolve governance disclosures
While funds around the world do a good job of disclosing governance frameworks related to financial and investment risks, as revealed in the GPTB, but what is best practice for communicating governance around addressing large, one-off events such as the impact of COVID or war?
GPTB shows pension transparency improvement
The transparency of pension fund disclosures has improved in the past year across the 15 countries and 75 pension funds measured in the Global Pension Transparency Benchmark, a collaboration between Top1000funds.com and CEM Benchmarking.
Innovation needed on fund disclosure of corporate strategy
A minority of pension funds reviewed for the GPTB publicly disclosure their organizational strategy in a way that goes beyond disclosures of economic and market conditions and the impact on the performance of their investments. Michael Reid argues there is room for improvement in communicating key corporate activities to stakeholders.
Please note, your details will be shared with both CEM and Top1000funds.com. Your data will never be shared with any other organisations or third parties.